Is there a way to Object.freeze() a JavaScript Date?

According to MDN Object.freeze() documentation:

The Object.freeze() method freezes an object: that is, prevents new properties from being added to it; prevents existing properties from being removed; and prevents existing properties, or their enumerability, configurability, or writability, from being changed. In essence the object is made effectively immutable. The method returns the object being frozen.

I was expecting that calling freeze on a date would prevent changes to that date, but it does not appear to be working. Here's what I am doing (running Node.js v5.3.0):

let d = new Date()
Object.freeze(d)
d.setTime(0)
console.log(d) // Wed Dec 31 1969 16:00:00 GMT-0800 (PST)

I would have expected the call to setTime to either fail or do nothing. Any ideas how to freeze a date?

5500 次浏览
小开

From MDN's docs on Object.freeze (emphasis mine):

Values cannot be changed for data properties. Accessor properties (getters and setters) work the same (and still give the illusion that you are changing the value). Note that values that are objects can still be modified, unless they are also frozen.

The Date object's setTime method isn't changing a property of the Date object, so it continues to work, despite having frozen the instance.

小开
最佳答案

Is there a way to Object.freeze() a JavaScript Date?

I don't think so. You can get close, though, see under the line below. But first let's see why just Object.freeze doesn't work.

I was expecting that calling freeze on a date would prevent changes to that date...

It would if Date used an object property to hold its internal time value, but it doesn't. It uses a [[DateValue]] internal slot instead. Internal slots aren't properties:

Internal slots correspond to internal state that is associated with objects and used by various ECMAScript specification algorithms. Internal slots are not object properties...

So freezing the object doesn't have any effect on its ability to mutate its [[DateValue]] internal slot.

You can freeze a Date, or effectively so anyway: Replace all its mutator methods with no-op functions (or functions that throw an error) and then freeze it. But as observed by zzzzBov (nice one!), that doesn't prevent someone from doing Date.prototype.setTime.call(d, 0) (in a deliberate attempt to get around the frozen object, or as a byproduct of some complicated code they're using). So it's close, but no cigar.

Here's an example (I'm using ES2015 features here, since I saw that let in your code, so you'll need a recent browser to run it; but this can be done with ES5-only features as well):

"use strict";


let d = new Date();
freezeDate(d);
d.setTime(0);
console.log(d);


function nop() {}


function freezeDate(d) {
allNames(d).forEach((name) => {
if (name.startsWith("set") && typeof d[name] === "function") {
d[name] = nop;
}
});
Object.freeze(d);
return d;
}
function allNames(obj) {
const names = Object.create(null); // Or use Map here


for (let thisObj = obj; thisObj; thisObj = Object.getPrototypeOf(thisObj)) {
Object.getOwnPropertyNames(thisObj).forEach((name) => {
names[name] = 1;
});
}
return Object.keys(names);
}
<!-- Script provides the `snippet` object, see http://meta.stackexchange.com/a/242144/134069 -->
<script src="//tjcrowder.github.io/simple-snippets-console/snippet.js"></script>

I think all the mutator methods of Date start with set, but if not it's easy to tweak the above.

小开

You could wrap it in a class like structure and define custom getters and setters in order to prevent an undesired change

小开

This is a really good question!

T.J. Crowder's answer has an excellent solution, but it got me thinking: What else can we do? How can we go around the Date.prototype.setTime.call(yourFrozenDate)?

1st attempt: "Wrapper"

One direct way is to provide an AndrewDate function which wraps a date. It has everything a date has minus the setters:

function AndrewDate(realDate) {
var proto = Date.prototype;
var propNames = Object.getOwnPropertyNames(proto)
.filter(propName => !propName.startsWith('set'));


return propNames.reduce((ret, propName) => {
ret[propName] = proto[propName].bind(realDate);
return ret;
}, {});
}


var date = AndrewDate(new Date());
date.setMonth(2); // TypeError: d.setMonth is not a function

What this does is create an object which has all the properties that an actual date object has and uses Function.prototype.bind to set their this.

This isn't a fool proof way of gathering around the keys, but hopefully you can see my intention.

But wait...looking at it a little further here and there, we can see that there's a better way of doing this.

2nd attempt: Proxies

function SuperAndrewDate(realDate) {
return new Proxy(realDate, {
get(target, prop) {
if (!prop.startsWith('set')) {
return Reflect.get(target, prop);
}
}
});
}


var proxyDate = SuperAndrewDate(new Date());

And we solved it!

...sort of. See, Firefox is the only one right now which implements proxies, and for some bizarre reasons date objects can't be proxied. Furthermore, you'll notice that you can still do things like 'setDate' in proxyDate and you'll see completions in console. To overcome that more traps need to be provided; specifically, has, enumerate, ownKeys, getOwnPropertyDescriptor and who knows what weird edge cases there are!

...So on second thought, this answer is nearly pointless. But at least we had fun, right?

小开

The accepted answer is actually flawed, I'm afraid. You actually can freeze an instance of any object including an instance of Date. In support of @zzzzBov's answer, freezing an object instance does not imply the object's state becomes constant.

证明Date实例真正冻结的一种方法是执行以下步骤:

var date = new Date();
date.x = 4;
console.log(date.x); // 4
Object.freeze(date);
date.x = 20; // this assignment fails silently, freezing has made property x to be non-writable
date.y = 5; // this also fails silently, freezing ensures you can't add new properties to an object
console.log(date.x); // 4, unchanged
console.log(date.y); // undefined

But you can achieve the behaviour I suppose you desire as follows:

var date = (function() {
var actualDate = new Date();


return Object.defineProperty({}, "value", {
get: function() {
return new Date(actualDate.getTime())
},
enumerable: true
});
})();


console.log(date.value); // Fri Jan 29 2016 00:01:20 GMT+0100 (CET)
date.value.setTime(0);
console.log(date.value); // Fri Jan 29 2016 00:01:20 GMT+0100 (CET)
date.value = null;       // fails silently
console.log(date.value); // Fri Jan 29 2016 00:01:20 GMT+0100 (CET)
小开

Making the date an integear is working for me:

let date = new Date();
const integerDate = Date.parse(date);
let unchangedDate = new Date(integerDate);
小开

Using a Proxy object is likely to be the best solution nowadays. Based on @Zirak's answer back in 2016, I've revised and improved the Proxy handler for maximum compatibility:

const noop = () => {}
const dateProxyHandler = {
get(target, prop, receiver) {
if (prop === Symbol.toStringTag) return "Date"
if (typeof prop === "string" && prop.startsWith("set")) return noop


const value = Reflect.get(target, prop, receiver)
return typeof value === "function" && prop !== "constructor"
? value.bind(target)
: value
},
}


function freeze(value) {
return value instanceof Date
? new Proxy(Object.freeze(new Date(Number(value))), dateProxyHandler)
: Object.freeze(value)
}


const frozenDate = freeze(new Date())


frozenDate.setHours(0) // noop
frozenDate.getHours() // works :)


JSON.stringify(frozenDate) // works :)


const copiedDate = new Date(Number(frozenDate)) // works :)


Object.prototype.toString.call(frozenDate) // "[object Date]"

Source: https://gist.github.com/sirlancelot/5f1922ef01e8006ea9dda6504fc06b8e


提交答案